- This event has passed.
AOE Webinar – Racial/Ethnic Biases in Clerkship Grading: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
January 26, 2022 @ 12:00 PM - 1:00 PM
Join us for “Racial/Ethnic Biases in Clerkship Grading: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis” with Rodney Arthur, Emma Marie Astrike-Davis, Colin Godwin, Michelle Ikoma, Mindy McKinney, and Bao-Tran Parker on Wednesday, January 26th, 2022, 12:00 – 1:00 PM EST via Zoom.
After registering, you will receive a confirmation email, with links to add to your personal calendars.
After pilot data from the UNC Class of 2019 demonstrated strong racial/ethnic disparities in clerkship grades (White students comprised 60% of the class but 73% of the top quartile), we undertook a meta-analysis of racial/ethnic biases in clerkship grading. This meta-analysis demonstrated strong racial/ethnic biases in clinical evaluations, standardized tests, and overall clerkship grades that did not fully reduce after introducing controlling factors, implying the existence of structural racism – likely mediated by stereotype threat and implicit or explicit biases – in clerkship grading. We contextualize the effects of these significant disparities in clerkship grading by discussing downstream disparities in AOA honors society eligibility and residency match success, both of which threaten the safety and academic progression of our students and, in turn, threaten patients through the deprivation of identity-concordant care in the most competitive residency fields. We will also provide general background on ways peer medical schools have combated these disparities, including Pass/Fail grading and reducing the influence of shelf exams, in anticipation of the formation of our Task Force on Competency Based Grading.
- Describe the direction and magnitude of structural racism in clerkship grading
- Quantify the magnitude of the downstream effects from racial/ethnic disparities in clerkship grading
- Describe structural racism in the context of clerkship grading
- Define stereotype threat and recognize how it affects student learning and accreditation
- Define implicit bias and recognize how it affects student learning and accreditation
- Describe the risks/benefits of Pass/Fail clerkship grading and halting medical student induction into AOA