Evidence-Based Program Review Process: Assessing if Applicants Meet the Administration for Community Living’s (ACL) Health Promotion Program Criteria
The purpose of the Evidence-Based Program Review Process is to identify new community programs that meet the criteria established by the Administration for Community Living (ACL) for evidence-based programs funded through the Older Americans Act (OAA) Title III-D, and other discretionary funding. It is important to note that Title III-D criteria specifically addresses older adults, but programs submitted through this process may address older adults and/or adults with disabilities. Operationalizing/clarifying recommendations for the criteria are available here.
The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill’s Thurston Arthritis Research Center (TARC) oversees the program review process in partnership with the Evidence-Based Leadership Collaborative (EBLC). UNC TARC and EBLC have established a Review Council to assess whether applicants meet the ACL Title III-D criteria for evidence-based programs. The Review Council consists of national leaders with expertise in program research, evaluation, and implementation. This process is supported by the National Chronic Disease Self-Management Education and Falls Prevention Resource Centers, funded by the Administration for Community Living, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services through Prevention and Public Health Funds (Grant numbers: 90CS0058 and 90FP0023).
The evidence-based program review process provides several benefits:
- Programs will be reviewed for potential inclusion on the ACL Title III-D approved list in a timely, unbiased manner;
- More programs targeting varied risk factors and populations will be available for dissemination; and
- Community, state, and tribal organizations/agencies can use the recommendations of the Review Council to reference programs that have been deemed to be appropriate for inclusion for ACL Title III-D, or other ACL future evidence-based program discretionary funding.
ACL Evidence-Based Program Criteria
Health promotion and disease prevention programs are reviewed based on the following criteria established by the Administration for Community Living:
- Demonstrated through evaluation to be effective for improving the health and well-being or reducing disease, disability and/or injury among older adults; and
- Proven effective with older adult population, using Experimental or Quasi-Experimental Design;* and
- Research results published in a peer-review journal; and
- Fully translated** in one or more community site(s); and
- Includes developed dissemination products that are available to the public.
The Review Council has further defined these criteria. The clarifying recommendations/guidance are available here.
The Review Council conducts a two-stage program application process:
Stage 1: The first stage application addresses the effectiveness, evidence, and evaluation details related to the program. Note that there are two separate Stage 1 applications: one application specifically for falls prevention programs, and another application for all other health promotion and disease prevention programs. Once evaluated by Review Council members with expertise in research and program evaluation, applicants will be notified whether or not they will be invited to complete the second stage of the application.
If a program is not approved to move to the second stage, applicants will be eligible to receive technical assistance provided by EBLC and may be able to re-apply during a subsequent review, depending on the recommendations of the Review Council.
Stage 2 (by invitation only): The second stage will require information about the program implementation, training, dissemination materials, supports available, and other elements essential for successful implementation.
UNC will facilitate one round of program reviews each year. The 2020 evidence-based program review process has been completed, and information about the 2021 review process will be posted on this website in January.
If you have questions about the Evidence-Based Program Review application process, please contact firstname.lastname@example.org.
**Photo acknowledgement: National Council on Aging, “Falls Prevention Photo Contest.”